My Ex's Hockey Rivals
Chapter 1 Fourteen Months of Promises

ELARA'S POV ‎"Hey, I'm heading over now. Can you open the door?" ‎I press send and shove my phone into my jacket pocket as Liam's townhouse comes into view, my steps automatically quickening. I have a surprise for him tucked under my arm-a limited edition watch he's been eyeing for months. I wanted to see the look on his face when he opens it. ‎As I walk faster, I recheck my phone, half expecting a reply, but there's nothing. Not even a typing bubble. A familiar warmth spreads through my chest. This is what fourteen months feels like: steady, predictable, safe. I know Liam's rhythms better than my own. He's probably still asleep, or maybe making coffee, taking his time because he doesn't have to rush to class today. One of the perks of taking a gap semester is that he doesn't have to treat academics like life or death the way I do. ‎I reach his townhouse and take the stairs two at a time, the gift box bouncing against my hip. The higher I climb, the more rushed my breathing feels, though it has less to do with the stairs and more to do with the creeping excitement that he hasn't texted back. By the time I get to the third floor, where his room is, I'm already picturing walking in and tossing a sarcastic comment about how hard it is to answer a simple text. ‎My hand reaches for his doorknob when I hear his voice through the door. Low. Guttural. Unmistakable. ‎"Yes, baby. Bend down for me." ‎I freeze. My hand hovers inches from the knob, the warmth in my chest turning to ice. The watch box suddenly feels heavy, stupid, naive. ‎"You need to leave," a girl's voice whispers breathlessly from inside. ‎The question barely forms before the door flies open and a girl rushes out, nearly colliding with me. She gasps, her eyes wide with panic, and bolts past me without a word. In the sliver of a second, I take in her messy red hair and wrinkled shirt. A sickening masculine scent-one I recognize very well-clings to her. ‎My gaze snaps to Liam. He's standing in the middle of the room completely naked, his hair tousled. But he isn't alone. On the bed behind him, another girl is still there. She isn't running. She's staying on the bed, smiling lazily as she leans in to kiss him, completely unbothered by my presence. ‎A cold shiver runs down my spine, stealing the air from my lungs. My knees go weak. Without a word, the girl on the bed disappears down the hallway. My fingers begin to tremble, and my heart hammers so hard it feels like it will burst through my ribs. I stumble back, a bitter taste rising in my throat. ‎"Liam, wait," his voice follows me as he steps into the hallway. "Baby, wait." ‎He freezes as he sees the gift box in my hand. His eyes dart from it to my face, and for a moment, genuine shock flickers across his features. Then the mask slides back into place. He starts stammering, pulling at nothing to cover himself. "It is not what you think! Elara, please, she was the one that forced herself to me! I didn't want this!" ‎I don't run. I don't scream. I just stand there, completely silent and cold, staring at him as if he's a stranger. The silence stretches, thick and suffocating, until he can't bear it anymore. ‎He tugs me toward his room, his grip tight. "It's better if we go inside. Everyone can hear us out here." ‎Inside, I shove him away, my chest rising and falling with quick breaths. I want to demand answers, but I already know the truth. The evidence is everywhere: in the rumpled sheets, the scent of perfume, and the desperate, guilty look in his eyes. ‎He paces the room, running a hand through his hair before stopping and grabbing my shoulder. "I messed up, okay? It was a mistake." ‎My eyes twitch. "A mistake?" ‎"Yeah, baby," he says, his eyes skittering away from mine. "Some of the guys came over last night. We drank too much. I got so wasted... I thought she was you. I don't even remember half of it." ‎I blink, unable to process his words. Did he really just say that? Does he actually expect me to believe this pathetic lie? I stare at him, waiting for him to take the hint, but he just holds my gaze, searching my face as if trying to see if I'm stupid enough to swallow it. ‎Then, his expression shifts. The guilt vanishes, replaced by something colder. Defensive. ‎"But honestly, Elara?" he snaps, his voice losing the fake pleading tone. "You're always so busy with your own life. Debate, magazines, that lame club... You put everything else before me. I just needed someone who actually had time for me." ‎The air in the room seems to vanish. It's not the grand, villainous declaration I might have expected. It's worse. It's petty. It's the sound of a boy who refuses to take responsibility for his own choices, twisting my ambition into his excuse. ‎I don't say a word. I don't argue. I simply raise my hand and slap him across the face. The sound cracks through the silence like a gunshot. ‎Liam's head snaps to the side. For a second, there is only silence. He slowly turns his face back to me, his hand rising to touch the red mark blooming on his skin. His eyes aren't filled with regret. They're filled with shock. And then, something worse. Resentment. ‎"You..." he chokes out, his voice rough. "You actually hit me?" ‎I don't answer. I just stand there, my hand still tingling, my chest heaving. My mind is a chaotic storm of images: the girl smiling on the bed, Liam naked and unbothered, the watch box still clutched in my other hand like a stupid, naive trophy. ‎"Elara, are you serious right now?" he insists, his voice rising. "She came on to me first. How was I supposed to resist when I was drunk? Come on, you know I love you." ‎A bitter laugh escapes my lips. It sounds foreign, jagged and broken. ‎"Cheating is one thing, Liam," I snap, taking a step toward him. My legs feel like lead, but my anger is a fuel I can't ignore. "But thinking I'm stupid enough to believe your lies? That's a whole other level." ‎He recoils as if I've physically struck him again. His voice grows colder. "You're overreacting." ‎"Overreacting?" The word tears from my throat. "Fourteen months, Liam! Fourteen months of promises, and you've broken every single one! And you have the nerve to tell me I'm overreacting?" ‎He scoffs, his mask finally dropping completely. The boy I thought I knew vanishes, replaced by a stranger wearing his face. "Promises? You really want to bring that up? Fine. Let's talk about promises. You promised your schedule would never affect us. How's that working out?" ‎"That's not-" I start, but he cuts me off. ‎"I play sports, and I still make time for you!" he yells, and I flinch. He notices, and a cruel smirk touches his lips. "You know what? This happened because of you, not me. You!" ‎I step back, rage crawling up my spine like ice water. Never in a million years did I imagine that the person I had loved and trusted for a whole year could be like this-twisting the truth, blaming me, acting as if I were at fault. ‎"You are a coward, Liam," I whisper, lifting my head to meet his eyes. "That's what you are. Blaming me, twisting everything, and calling it my fault? I'm done." ‎I dash to his desk, sending papers and books tumbling to the floor as I hunt for my textbook. I need to get out of here before my anger takes over. ‎"You act like there's someone better out there," he sneers from behind me. "There isn't, and there won't ever be." ‎I pause, staring up at him. He steps closer, his voice rising. "You were nobody before me, Elara. I made you popular. People know your name because of me." ‎Something inside me snaps. I close the distance between us, breathing against his face. "You will never speak to me again," I hiss. "And mark my words, you will be replaced by someone hotter, smarter, and better than you could ever be." ‎I yank the couple necklace he gave me off my neck and fling it at his feet. Without another word, I storm out with my textbook, tears burning my eyes. I managed not to cry in front of him, but as I run down the stairs, the dam finally bursts. ‎I collapse against the side of the building, clutching my chest as sobs tear out of me. It feels like someone has ripped my heart away. Our memories stab me over and over. ‎My phone buzzes in my pocket, and I fumble to answer it, my hands shaking. "Yeah?" I sniffle, wiping my tears. My brother's voice floats through. ‎"Don't forget you promised to tutor Aris after class today," Jake says, sounding annoyed. "He's already bugging me." ‎I bite my lip, wanting to tell him I can't right now, not in this state, but I had promised to help his friend. I exhale, pushing back the lump in my throat, and slowly rise to my feet. ‎"Okay," I manage to say.

Chapter 2 Tutor, Rival, Disaster

ARIS'S POV ‎The engine of my bike cuts out, leaving only the hum of the city and the pounding in my own chest. I pull into the apartment lot, killing the ignition. For a moment, I just sit there, gripping the handlebars, staring at myself in the side mirror. My knuckles are scraped from practice, and there's a fresh bruise blooming on my jaw where Stan checked me into the boards yesterday. ‎If I fail Business Ethics, Dad pulls my funding. No hockey. No scholarship. Just a desk job at the firm I hate, watching Liam take my starting spot while I rot in a cubicle. The thought makes my stomach clench. ‎"You got this," I tell myself. "Just get in, get laid, get out." ‎Lucky for me, Jake's kid sister, Elara, is supposed to be tutoring me later. All I need is a few sessions with her to keep my grades up so hockey stays mine. That's the plan. The smart plan. But right now, before that headache starts, I need something to shut my brain off. I need a distraction before I lose it completely. ‎I nod to myself, shove the door open, and head for the building. As I walk past the courtyard, an elderly woman struggles with a bag of groceries. Without thinking, I stop and carry it to her door. She thanks me with a warm smile, and for a second, the knot in my chest loosens. Then I shake it off and keep moving. ‎I slow as I near my door, spotting someone leaning against the frame. He lifts his head, eyes locking with mine, and a smirk curls his lips. ‎Becca. Exactly the distraction I ordered. I'd shot him a text twenty minutes ago, but didn't think he'd make it so quickly. ‎"Guess hot," he purrs, his voice low and rough. ‎He's wearing nothing but an unbuttoned denim jacket and dark jeans. He pushes off the wall, stepping into my space, and shoots me a look that says I'm about to make you forget everything. ‎My gaze drags over him as I slip the key into the lock. "Is that all for me?" ‎His eyes glitter in the dim hallway light. "Sure, big guy." ‎I've barely stepped inside before his hands are on me. I waste no time closing the distance between us. The world outside the door-the frustrations of the day, my father's ultimatum, my grades-they all fade into a distant hum. There is only this. Only the heat and the sharp, desperate need to feel something other than failure. ‎Two hours later, Becca is snuggled up beside me on the couch, his head resting on my chest. He traces meaningless lines across my skin, a gesture of intimacy that makes my stomach tighten. I don't like the cuddly stuff. It makes me feel trapped. It feels like a promise I never made. ‎I slowly shift, dislodging his head, and reach for my shorts on the floor. ‎"I missed you," he blurts, cutting through the silence. ‎I spin, caught off guard for half a second before I reel it back in. Did he forget the rules? ‎We first hooked up three months ago, and I was crystal clear about my boundaries. Things were easy because he was fine with a no-strings-attached arrangement. No feelings. No future. Just stress relief. But now, hearing those words? It feels like a trap. ‎"I've been busy," I mutter, dragging on my shorts. I can't say I missed him too, because that'll only mess things up. But the truth is, he hadn't crossed my mind once since we last hooked up. I'm too exhausted. Got practice in an hour, and I still have to read three chapters of Business Ethics. ‎"Are you really kicking me out minutes after we just had sex?" Becca snaps, sitting up. His voice rises, edged with hurt. "Seriously, Aris. Is this it?" ‎He looks visibly upset now. "I thought we were clear about this." ‎"From the very beginning, I told you I'm not looking for anything serious," I say, my voice firm. Cold. "No strings attached. Just this." ‎His fingers tremble as he snatches his jacket off the floor. "Well, I don't want to be your whenever-you-want boy anymore. I want to be your boyfriend." ‎"You know that's not happening," I respond flatly. ‎"But why?" he demands, his voice cracking. ‎"I don't have to explain myself, and don't act like I tricked you. You knew the deal from day one." I tilt my head toward the door. "If casual wasn't your thing, you shouldn't have agreed. Now do us both a favor and leave." ‎His expression immediately softens, his eyes filling with a plea. "Big guy," he croaks, his voice breaking. "I just... I just really like you. Can't you-" ‎He lifts a hand to touch my arm, and I take a sharp step back. ‎His hand is left hanging in the air. His eyes turn cold instantly. The vulnerability is gone, replaced by a cutting anger. ‎"Why exactly can't I be your boyfriend?" he asks, his voice hard. "What is it? Do you have a checklist I don't measure up to?" ‎I don't answer. I turn and stride out of the bedroom. He follows, his shoes thudding on the hardwood floor, but I ignore him. I pass the dining table, head straight for the fridge, and crack open a beer. ‎He stops short, the anger in his body suddenly replaced with bewildered hurt. "So that's it? You're just going to grab a beer? You don't even care, do you?" ‎I take a slow sip, not looking at him. "I thought we were clear. I don't." ‎"I can be a good boyfriend!" he pleads, his voice rising. "I'm great. Just give me a chance." ‎I shake my head. "I don't need a boyfriend." ‎The words hang in the air for a moment before something in him breaks. He lets out a frustrated cry and yells, "Screw you!" ‎He lunges for the front door, yanking it open. He dashes out and almost collides with a girl coming down the hall, a stack of books in her arms. She sidesteps to avoid being hit, clutching the textbooks against her chest like a shield. ‎It's Elara. ‎Becca gives her a slow once-over, then whips back to me with a sneer. "Really? I thought you had standards." ‎My mouth opens, ready to shut him down, but Elara beats me to it. Unlike Becca, she actually has a purpose. Her eyes are red-rimmed, her face pale and tight with barely contained rage. She looks like she's been through a war zone. ‎"Relax," Elara says, her voice dangerously quiet. "I'm not here to hook up with him. Unlike you, I actually have a purpose." ‎Both of us freeze. My brows furrow, caught off guard. Becca's smirk falters, and for a split second, he looks like he's been slapped. ‎Becca scoffs, recovering his composure. "Whatever. Have fun tutoring, nerd." He slams the door behind him, the sound echoing through the hallway. ‎Silence stretches between Elara and me. Thick. Suffocating. ‎She smells like vanilla and old paper-a stark contrast to Becca's expensive cologne and desperation. But there's no warmth in her gaze. Only ice. ‎"So," I say, my voice rougher than I intended. I gesture to the apartment with my beer bottle. "You're the genius Jake won't shut up about?" ‎Elara doesn't flinch. She just stares at me, her eyes dark and exhausted. There's no flirtation in them, no hunger. Just a cold, hard assessment. Like she's already decided I'm not worth the effort. Or worse-like she sees me as just another guy who's going to let her down. ‎"I'm the tutor," she corrects quietly, her voice clipped. "And you're late." ‎I glance at the clock on the microwave. Shit. She's right. ‎"Right," I mutter, taking another sip of beer to buy myself a second. "Come in, then. Let's get this over with." ‎She steps inside, closing the door softly behind her. She doesn't look at the mess on the floor where Becca's jacket still lies. She just walks past me, heading straight for the kitchen table like she owns the place. ‎But as she passes, I catch the faint scent of tears beneath the vanilla. And the way her jaw is clenched so tight it looks like it might shatter. ‎And for the first time all week, my bad mood shifts. Not because I'm happy. But because Elara isn't looking at me like I'm a prize to be won or a problem to be fixed. ‎She's looking at me like I'm just another assignment. Another guy who's probably going to fail her. ‎And somehow, that pisses me off more than Becca's tears ever could. Because I don't want to be just another disappointment. Even if I have no idea how to prove it.

Chapter 3 The Deal

ELARA'S POV The redhead glares at me, her chest rising and falling like she's trying to push the anger out in measured breaths. I wait for a retort, but she spares me only a cutting look, huffs at Aris in dismissal, and storms off, muttering curses to herself. I stare after her, gritting my teeth as irritation prickles my skin. What's it with me and redheads today? First, with Liam in the morning, and now his teammate. It seems they both have a type. Or maybe I just attract men who think women are interchangeable. A low chuckle from the doorway yanks my attention back. Aris Vance leans casually against the frame, an infuriating smirk tugging at his lips. His abs are on full display, golden skin glowing against the light. Every line of him is impossible to ignore, which only makes me angrier. "Didn't think you had that in you," he says, tilting his head toward my chest. I glance down and there it is: a peach, drawn smack in the center of my shirt. Heat rises to my cheeks-not from embarrassment, but from the sheer audacity. I roll my eyes, letting out a dry scoff. "Why?" His voice hums with amusement, even though I refuse to look at him. "Getting a little distracted by the view?" I spin around, crossing my arms over the stupid drawing. "Ever heard of the word decency?" I snap. "It's spelled D-E-C..." "Hey, I can spell that. What do you take me for?" he cuts in, feigning annoyance, which somehow makes it even more irritating. He shuts the door and strolls over to the eat-in counter. A can of beer sits there, and before my eyes, he tilts it back and gulps down the entire thing in one smooth motion. "Is that alcohol?" I ask, fists clenching at my sides. My stomach twists. After what I saw in his room, the last thing I need is a drunk hockey player. He shoots me a strange look, eyes flicking to the now-squashed can in his hand. "It's beer... so yes, I'm pretty sure it's alcohol." He tilts his head, his smirk creeping back. "Aren't you supposed to be the smarter one?" Anger bubbles inside me, hot and acidic. Did Jake not tell him I'm coming over? But no, Jake called me this morning to remind me. So, Aris knows I'm here to tutor, not watch him get drunk or relive his hookup with Becca. "You're drinking on a night I'm supposed to tutor you?" I demand, my voice tight. I keep my gaze fixed on his face, refusing to let it drop to his bare chest again. He sighs dramatically and tosses the can in the trash. "Don't be so peachy," he says, his voice teasing. "It's just one can and it's not enough to knock me out. Besides... we can just get to know each other today. Jake definitely didn't mention you've grown into a pretty woman." I feel irritation crawl up my spine, and my lips twitch. My eyes dart to the door, tempted to leave. I don't have time for this. I don't have the emotional bandwidth to deal with another arrogant athlete treating me like a conquest. But then I remember Jake's pleading and the one thousand dollars he promised for my new MacBook. I need that money. I need to prove I can handle this without crumbling. I fix him with a death glare, forcing my voice to stay steady. "First of all, don't call me that again. Second, have you considered that the reason you're flunking your courses is that you flirt too much, and let's not forget your unhealthy obsession with hockey? If you actually stop thinking about ways to flirt with me, maybe we can get something done tonight. But if you don't, I'll be more than happy to waste your time and watch you fail." "Do you have friends?" he throws at me casually, catching me off guard. "Or have they all ghosted you because all you do is read and forget to socialize?" His words sting, bringing back the memory of what Liam said to me this morning-*You put everything else before me.* The accusation feels like a physical blow, but I swallow the hurt. I won't give him the satisfaction of seeing me bleed. "You must be so good at socializing that you forget other things matter," I lift my book, using it like a shield. "Oh, things like graduating from college. Or keeping your scholarship." His smirk widens, and I can see he's taking this as a challenge. Is my insistence... kind of a kink for him? Or does he just enjoy watching me squirm? "Now, where's your room? Let's get started," I add, keeping my voice calm. Professional. Detached. He leads the way to his room, and I follow, my eyes scanning the space as I enter. Posters of the Chicago Blackhawks cover the walls, along with a few other players I recognize from Jake's room. Surprisingly, it's cleaner than I expected, until my gaze lands on his bed. The sheets are scattered, and two empty condom wrappers lie on the floor. Bile rises in my throat. The scent of sex and cheap cologne hangs heavy in the air. It's exactly like Liam's room this morning. The evidence of another girl, another mistake, another moment where I wasn't enough. I bolt out, clutching my books to my chest like armor, heat flooding my face. He follows, a look of amused surprise on his face, but I don't slow down. "We'll just read here," I say, refusing to meet his eyes. I drop my books on the table, my hand aching from carrying them too long. My knuckles are white. Aris prowls closer, shrinking the air between us. The smell of him-clean soap, faint sweat, and something distinctly male-wraps around me. "Why'd you run like that?" he asks. "Can't handle being in the same room with me?" That damn nickname again. My patience frays, snapping like a thin wire. "You should clean up your room after sex, especially if you've got company. It's called decency. Maybe you've heard of it, though clearly, you haven't." His fingers suddenly tilt my jaw, forcing my eyes to his. His touch is warm, calloused, and startlingly gentle for someone so large. "Are you sure that's the only reason? You know I can make time for you." That's it. I've had enough. Heat floods my chest as I snatch my books off the table and storm toward the door. "Find someone else!" I yell, my voice cracking slightly. I hate that crack. I hate that he can still get under my skin. He catches my arm, trying to stop me, but I yank hard against his grip. I will not sit through two hours of his shameless flirting; not today. Not after the day I've had. Not after Liam. "Hey, I'm sorry, okay?" Aris's voice softens as he pleads, his grip loosening but not letting go. "I'll behave, alright?" he rushes out. "I'll put on a shirt, never say another word you don't like. Just, please, tutor me. I'm desperate." I whirl around, ready to snap that he doesn't act desperate enough, when my pocket starts buzzing nonstop. With a huff, I yank my phone out, half-expecting one of my study group members. Hoping for a distraction. But no, it's Liam. My stomach knots as I click the notification. Instead of apologies like I imagined for a second-a pathetic, hopeful part of me always expects apologies-my screen is filled with vile messages from him. My throat burns as my eyes lock on the one message that makes the rest blur away. *~LIAM: Return my hoodie. My new girl wants it.~* Everything else fades as hot anger sears through me. I read the line twice, but the words don't change. He wants me to return his hoodie?! The one he wore when he told me he loved me. And not just that; he already has a new girl, less than twelve hours after we broke up. My jaw clenches so tight it aches. He's doing this to rile me up, to prove he's moved on, to prove I was nothing. And goddamn, it's working. If I don't hit back, he wins. He gets to be the victim. He gets to be the one who moved on first. The memory of him sneering that I'd never find someone better than him scorches me deeply. *You were nobody before me, Elara.* "Hey." A tap on my shoulder jolts me, and Aris's voice snaps me out of my thoughts. "Did you hear a word I said?" My head jerks toward him, and it takes a moment to recollect myself, his last word lingering in my mind. *Anything you want.* The words replay like a chant, and suddenly my mind is crawling with ideas that shouldn't be there. Dangerous ideas. Revenge-fueled ideas. My gaze rakes down his frame and back up, assessing him not as a man, but as a weapon. He catches it, brows pulling together in confusion. I shouldn't even be thinking about it. This is reckless. This is petty. But the thought is so damn tempting. Aris Vance, the campus golden boy and star forward of the hockey team. He's the guy girls would do anything to be seen with, and guys hate him because he can take their girlfriends with a smile. He might be a player, but everyone knows he's picky. Ruthlessly picky. So much so that girls brag if they even make it into his bed. Just being seen with him is enough to boost your social status overnight. You get invitations to events just because you've caught the eye of Aris Vance. And right now, he's standing in front of me, saying *anything I want*. Not just because of who he is, but because he's Liam's teammate. Because he's the exact opposite of Liam in every way that matters to the campus gossip mill. What better way to grind Liam's inflated ego to dust than to show him his so-called replaceable ex is on the arm of his hotter, more desirable, and infinitely more famous rival? I turn to face Aris fully, heat prickling under my skin. Not attraction. Strategy. Pure, cold strategy. "You'll do anything?" I ask, watching him closely. My voice is steady now. The tremor is gone. He studies me, uncertainty flickering in his eyes for the first time since I walked in. He senses the shift. The danger. Still, he nods. "Yeah." I take a slow breath, steadying the heat in my voice. I lock eyes with him, making sure he sees the resolve, not the heartbreak. "Then here's the deal. I'll tutor you, and not just enough for you to pass. You'll ace your classes, every single one of them, with at least a B. That's my part." He narrows his eyes, waiting. The air between us crackles with unspoken terms. "And yours?" "In return," I say, my voice dropping to a whisper that carries the weight of a vow, "you'll use your charm, your connections, your golden-boy reputation to pursue me. Publicly. You will make everyone believe we are madly in love. And you will make sure Liam sees it."

Continue reading